Blog Entry No.3: Music and Gender
Hello everyone! Fall is finally upon us. The leaves are changing colors, the air is getting crisp and chilled. Out of curiosity, does anyone else have their taste in music change along with the season? I feel like mine does. You know what else changes? Gender roles! Gender roles in music has definitely changed over the years from jobs to clothing choices to music. Since this is for a music class, we are going to talk about how gender has changed in music and how being a biological female has affected me when it comes to music.
I have never been into playing an instrument. It has never been my forte if I am being honest, but I used to be in marching band as a color guard member and one thing I remember so vividly was one of my friends was the only girl on the drumline. People always joked that she was the little sister of the group or she was just one of the guys, but she is an amazing drummer! She really enjoyed it and it made her unique. My last year of marching band, I overheard a couple of the male drummers talking about how more girls were on drumline after tryouts and they didn't sound too happy about it. I never understood why because if you have ever seen a marching band uniform, everyone looks the exact same so it's not like the audience would be able to tell who was a guy and who was a girl. It always just struck me as odd. On the flip side, there was only one guy who played the flute. The rest were all girls. In marching band, there were a few instruments that seemed to have a nice mix of men and women and the occasional nonbianary like trumpets and front ensemble, but baritones were primarily guys as were tubas. Woodwinds like flute and clarinet were typically girls. I'm not sure if it is still the same since it's been about 2 years since I have been in a marching band show, but those were some things that just stood out to me.
Another way I've seen gender play a role in music is women are not supposed to be into rock, heavy metal, alt, punk. That is something I've always seen as a general rule. People would ask me what type of music do I listen to and list off singers like Taylor swift, One Direction, Justin Beiber, singers that are very pop music based. When I would say a rockband like Queen or AC/DC or Greenday, guys would sort've "test" me? I would get asked questions like 'Oh, you like Greenday? Name 5 of their songs.' I've seen a lot of gatekeeping especially from guys like that. I don't know if it was because I was a girl wearing bows and pink skirts, but I don't think that my femininity has anything to do with what I listen to. I can listen to Ghost while I put on my eyeliner. I will listen to Mindless Self Indulgence while I put on earrings and hairclips. It's all because music shouldn't have an influence on gender identity. Listening to Katy Perry does not make you less of a man. Listening to Set It Off does not make you less of a woman. And it doesn't have to be just rock vs pop music. Guys can listen to musicals, girls can listen to rap, just as long as we can agree that music is good.
Sorry if my blog seemed more like a rant this time around, I promise mine will not always be a soap box speech but I hope that I can leave you with a good note with one of my favorite videos of woman singing something that is light and fancy and feminine and switching to something that would be seen as masculine.

Your blog was great! I enjoyed how you opened up with the changing of the seasons and slowly transitioned into the topic. It is also very enjoyable how you included your own personal experience into your blog, it helps us to get to know you better and I find it much more interesting when people include their personal experience. I also hope that the culture of the drumline is different! I know at my school, we had quite a few females on the drumline.
ReplyDeleteI loved this blog, I totally understand what you mean when you say people always quiz or interrogate you when you say what you listen to and because of that I constantly change what I listen to depending on who is around. When I am with my dad I like to lean more towards the rock/ older music, when I am with my sister it become strictly rap, and with my friends I get to listen to my alt music. I feel like we def put a lot of pressure on ourselves to listen to the best music and to always impress people with our music when really all we need to do is just enjoy it.
ReplyDeleteThis is random, but I remember when band tees became fashionable for girls to wear and guys were extremely upset by it. I remember them gatekeeping the tee shirts and quizzing girls on their knowledge of the band. It was pretty ridiculous to see them upset by a t-shirt. I enjoyed your blog and thought you presented good points. Also, the girl in the video left the judges shook!
ReplyDeleteI absolutely loved this blog! I remember getting my first rock band tee in middle school (Green Day) and EVERY guy would ask me if I knew some of their less popular songs to test my knowledge in a strange way. Then, I got a Slipknot shirt and guys at my school lost their minds. I've always hated people doubting my knowledge of a band just because I'm a girl. Honestly, if I want to wear a Breaking Benjamin shirt, go ahead and assume that I listen to them lol. I really liked the video by the way!
ReplyDelete